VIP. Even if you have never read it, if you were ever disappointed in the Hobbit trilogy because of various bad filmmaking decisions, silliness, or Makes no sense at all, drop weapons so all of them can die instead of just Bilbo? But after watching it over and over, I felt like it could be condensed without losing too much, so a 7-minute scene was then cut down to 2 minutes. I just want to watch a coherent Hobbit movie, okay? This was the most exciting sequence in the film by far, and I feel would make for an exciting 40-minute (or so) film. I don't want to obsess over minutia. (This grade is based on the Maple Films' J.R.R. Tolkien's The Hobbit (Maple Films) The Spence Edit; The Hobbit Recut; The Bilbo Edition; The Two Hour Edit (Fiona) The Hobbit Biblical Cut The best edit for me is actually J.J. R. Tolkiens The Hobbit by Dustin Lee, and, judging by the fact that some of your qualifiers are most professional and most enjoyable, I think that you may agree with me. Maple Films edition had some beautiful gems as well. There is a lot to like about Jacksons Hobbit films, and I feel like part of the criticism stems from the dual fact that he a) diverged so much from the original source material (i.e. I recently watched a 4.5 hour fan edit of The Hobbit films. Tolkien's The Hobbit. I'm guessing the editors for both must have tracked down a pirated copy of BOTFA. Take your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat. very noss cover, [MENTION=28235]eldusto84[/MENTION]. Stay tuned! Please login to upload images - There are currently no 1:15 When people ask what you do for a living, what do you tell them? Und diesen Film kann man sich anschauen. Extraneous subplots, superfluous dialogue, and new characters that did not exist in Tolkien's original text have all been stuffed into this new Middle Earth trilogy. Has anyone else seen any good fan edits? THE PROS: There are many, many pros to this new edit. Durins Folk and the Hill of Sorcery. These are the fanedits. J.R.R. These new Hobbit films are practically begging for a proper fanedit. Upon its completion, 20th Century Man was accepted into nearly 20 film festivals around the world, including the Phoenix Film Festival and the Cleveland International Film Festival. Thank you! Then came David Killsteins Definitive Hobbit Cut, which showed how the film could be paced. I found it was the perfect length for a Hobbit fan edit and paced itself rather well. I'm already planning to keep "The Last Goodbye " over the credits, followed by Dreaming of Bag End or some other track. But one of my top beefs seems to be missed by most editors: during the troll scene, when they grab Bilbo and threaten to tear his limbs off unless the dwarves drop their weapons. Hey guys, about 4 months ago I finished this edit, which I worked on for about a year. I watched the two fan edits after making my own, private, fan edit for my friends and family to see, and wanted to see if any other people had the same ideas as I did. And absolutely ditch the High-Fells storyline, it's totally off base and unnecessary. Hide ads with . Tolkien's The Hobbit fan-edit, which combines all three HOBBIT films into one 4 hour-plus epic that eschews most of the plot elements that aren't straight from the book) And now we get to the point where even the most thorough editing can't fully compensate for Tolkien and Jackson's over-stuffed plotting. Even if you have never read it, if you were ever disappointed in the Hobbit trilogy because of various bad filmmaking decisions, silliness, or So what does all this mean? 2 Lists; Official Site IMDB TMDB Fanart.tv JustWatch Wikipedia; Refresh Data; Set Profile Image; Advertisement. There's a 4-hour "Tolkien edit" and a very lean 3-hour edit that have received the most interest from people so far. VIP. *JULY 2016 UPDATE: Direct download links available for the main fan edit AND Durin's Folk! J.R.R. Movie Titles; Music Artists; TV Shows; Music Labels; Everything else; What are you looking for? Production took place over the course of a week in March 2011, mostly in and around Kent, Ohio. The Maple Film, however, is a much more professional edit than The Bilbo Edition, and most of its cuts are seemless. See below. Tolkien's The Hobbit (Maple Films Edit) Fanart Released: 2016 - ID: 466741. J.R.R. That being said, I have been working on a purist version of Peter Jacksons Hobbit trilogy, with the ultimate goal of creating an alternate film that is as faithful to the original book as possible. Maple Films edition had some beautiful gems as well. This is meant to be as faithful to Bilbo and the spirit of Tolkiens book as possible, while still telling a complete story for the screen. While hardly the first fan edit of The Hobbit, Graces version may be one of the most palatable. Nov 8, 2017 4,438. Maple Films on Facebook The Hobbit fan edit Transistor Night Drive The Astronomer 20th Century Man Super Pimp College (the band) A Quiet House Show Notes. Fanedits of the Hobbit Trilogy [edit | edit source] 3-in-1 edits: The Dwarfed Edition; The Tolkien Edit; There and Back Again (Killstein) There and Back Again (A Hobbit's Cut) The Hobbit: An Expected Edit; The Angry Cut; J.R.R. J.R.R. Hobbit Fanedits Wiki is a FANDOM Movies Community. Azog is also approached differently in the two cuts. Love the "blurb" at the back. J.R.R. Someone called TolkienEditor has cut the three Peter Jackson The Hobbit movies down into a single 4-hour film and put the result up on BitTorrent. This is the main download page for J.R.R. Here are the most major ones. M4's Hobbit Book Edit I'm an aspiring video editor/audio engineer who has professionally re-cut Peter Jackson's Hobbit trilogy into one single movie that is much more accurate to J.R.R. Sometimes these CG effects work remarkably well and sometimes they look incredibly fake. I have been reading the Hobbit again, and it is quite light hearted. Tolkien's The Hobbit (Maple Films Fan Edit) - Official Trailer - YouTube. Tolkien's book. This was the first major short film production by Maple Films. The fan-edit is not exactly a new thing in film culture, but the highest quality one Ive watched and the easiest to procure is this one by Maple Films Dustin Lee. First, there was the Tolkein Edition. The Ironfoot Edition And these are the edits that probably exist, but I'm having a hard time finding a copy of. You can also send a message to the editor. Welcome to the Maple Films YouTube channel! 3:05 Do you find that creating films Just watched Maple Film's "JRR Tolkien's The Hobbit" fan edit last night and was BLOWN AWAY at how much of an improvement cutting 8+ hours down to a healthy 4 was for the story and characters, particularly Bilbo and his personal journey. One widely circulated fan edit in 2015, The Tolkien Edit, ran four hours long . The Hobbit: The Original Two-Film Structure, http://www.maple-films.com/jrr-tolkiens-the-hobbit, https://hobbitfanedits.fandom.com/wiki/J.R.R._Tolkien%27s_The_Hobbit_(Maple_Films)?oldid=163. How do you solve a problem like viewing order? Tolkiens The Hobbit (Maple Films Edit). clevbrowns95. Tolkien's The Hobbit (Maple Films Edit): This is one of two fan edits I watched of The Hobbit trilogy (the other being The Bilbo Edition). The Hobbit fan edit trailer by Maple films. posted by Jason Kottke Jan 22, 2015. Maple Films hat alle drei Filme in eine 4h-Version geschnitten, die mir die letzten beiden Abende sehr viel Freude bereitet hat: http://www.maple-films.com/jrr-tolkiens-the-hobbit Hier geht's zum Trailer des Fan Edits: https://youtu.be/85gVFD7Dqwk Ach ja, eigentlich sollte man im Besitz der Originaltrilogie sein. There & Back Again A Hobbits Tale Recut. Grace isnt exactly a stranger to fan edits of films in 2012, he famously trimmed down George Lucas Star Wars prequels into a now-legendary 85-minute film. Tolkiens The Hobbit is a fan-edit of the Hobbit trilogy by Dustin Lee of Maple Films.The edit removes the side plots and unnecessary additional scenes not present in the novel, consolidating the trilogy into one 4-hour film, and color-corrects the originally over-saturated picture to be more aesthetically pleasing and more consistent with the Lord of the Rings trilogy. What's more, many of the practical visual effects and beautiful real-world scenery of the original trilogy have given way to prequels that look and feel like high-end video games. Here you can find download links for the digital copy of the fan edit, DVD/Bluray ISO files, along with custom disc and box art. Im the editor of the Maple Films version of the Hobbit (JRR Tolkiens The Hobbit). Well, I finally did it. J.R.R. Put two faneditors in the same room, and you'll get three different cutlists - and five different versions. The Hobbit (M4 Book Edit) (Released) Author sidshady12 Date 7-Oct-2020, 6:35 PM Author sidshady12 Time 7-Oct-2020 6:35 PM Post link. Runtime 247 mins. 2 Lists; Official Site IMDB TMDB Fanart.tv JustWatch Wikipedia; Refresh Data; Set Profile Image; Advertisement. The Bilbo Edition, while a little choppier, is still very well done, and I think I really only notice the quality of the cuts because I am currently working on my own edit of the trilogy. Tolkien's The Hobbit (Maple Films Edit) Featured Hot. Tolkien's The Hobbit (Maple Films Edit) Fanart Released: 2016 - ID: 466741. J.R.R. M4's Hobbit Book Edit I'm an aspiring video editor/audio engineer who has professionally re-cut Peter Jackson's Hobbit trilogy into one single movie that is much more accurate to J.R.R. It was done very well and the entire film felt like Bilbo's story, as it should. Someone called TolkienEditor has cut the three Peter Jackson The Hobbit movies down into a single 4-hour film and put the result up on BitTorrent. This is my own take for a fan-edit of The Hobbit that stands worthy to the Lord of the Rings film, though it has been influenced by MANY other fan editors. The 'Maple edit' is probably the best-received re-cut of Jackson's Hobbit films up to now, attempting to be as faithful as possible to the original book. Excellent! I'd like some opinions on this clip. The Maple Films edition got my attention, but after reading your review, I believe The Bilbo Edition is the closest to what Ive always wanted The Hobbit films to be than any other fan cut Ive watched. In preparation for the March 24 release of Battle of Five Armies, I decided to start making my box art for JRR TOLKIEN'S THE HOBBIT. Then came David Killsteins Definitive Hobbit Cut, which showed how the film could be paced. Things like the Bombur barrel sequence don't fit with the vibe, but some of the Radagast scenes do. But shouldn't there be SOME kind of laws of physics in them? ", *Also created Durin's Folk and the Hill of Sorcery (6/15/8/2015 [12/8/2015]; 1:09 hrs). WE CURRENTLY HAVE 2 IMAGES IN THIS SECTION. Hide ads with . The Maple Film is a more professional edit, with some nice color correction and nearly seamless cuts, that edits the story down to be way more enjoyable. That said, I do still prefer the Maple Films fan edit, it just feels a lot richer in terms of character, and its use of extended edition scenes make for Tolkien's The Hobbit (Maple Films Fan Edit) - Official Trailer One of my favorite aspects of this edit is the return of focus to Bilbos story. Tolkien's The Hobbit (Maple Films Fan Edit) - Official Trailer. Hide ads with . Please login to make requests. download link: .. sorryiloveyou ptolomeus Ive been constantly updating it and working it with new feedback, but now I think I am very close to being done, if not done already. That's a good point, I will keep that in mind. These are fantasy movies, I get that. Eldusto84s The Hobbit Wins August 2016 FEOTM by MCP on October 3, 2016 Posted in Fanediting Bits, Site News After a slightly contentious month for Favorite Edit of the Month, Eldusto84 took home the Favorite Edit of the Month for August 2016 with his J.R.R. Like most Tolkien fans, I found the trilogy disappointing. With that being said, here is a list of my planned edits for the third and final Hobbit film. Check out the Maple Films edit. Of course there are some difficulties that are impossible to overcome entirely due to the limitations caused by what was shot and what was left out or changed (sometimes radically changed). I found some great reviews of one from Maple Films (JRR Tolkiens The Hobbit), but that edit I guess came out in 2015 and was entirely based on the Theatrical Editons, so there has to be more options by now. That being said, I have been working on a purist version of Peter Jacksons Hobbit trilogy, with the ultimate goal of creating an alternate film that is as faithful to the original book as possible. A fan edit of The Hobbit trilogy by Maple Films that cuts out all the pointless scenes, cartoonish antics, and focuses the story back to where it should have been all along: On the journey of Bilbo Baggins and the company of Dwarves. 27 reviews. Please login to make requests . The Hobbit: The Tolkien Edit. So, these are the edits I've been able to find: The Tolkien Edit. makes the project look like a tome of magic. Then came David Killsteins Definitive Hobbit Cut, which showed how the film could be paced. Tolkien's The Hobbit (Maple Films Edit): This is one of two fan edits I watched of The Hobbit trilogy (the other being The Bilbo Edition). Needs to go! A Quiet House went on to win the Best Film award at that years Cleveland 48HFP and screened at Filmapalooza the following March in Seattle. First, there was the Tolkein Edition. There are numerous fan-edits to choose from, but the highest quality one Ive watched and the easiest to procure is this one by Maple Films Dustin Lee. J.R.R. (This grade is based on the Maple Films' J.R.R. VIP. I can forgive the downsides I referred to before, since I couldnt appreciate all the hard work youve invested into this any more than I already am. For my second fanedit, Ive decided to make a version of Rogue One that revolves entirely around the Battle of Scarif. Maple Films website Maple Films on Facebook The Hobbit fan edit Transistor Night Drive The Astronomer 20th Century Man Super Pimp College (the band) Personally, I was impressed with the Maple Films Fan Edit. Their goal was to make the film hew more closely to the book, put the focus back on Bilbo as the main character, and to quicken the pace of the narrative. Maple Films edition had some beautiful gems as well. Then the Underhill Editors There and Back Again absolutely blew our minds. This was the first major short film production by Maple Films. If that doesn't work THEN post in the Trade & Request forum. It's an enjoyable watch. Runtime 247 mins. Put two faneditors in the same room, and you'll get three different cutlists - and five different versions. Tolkien's The Hobbit (Maple Films Edit) Overview; Activity; All comments.
Child Health Department Parkway 5 Manchester, Redditch Tip Coronavirus, Nourishmax Eye Cream Ingredients, Cambridge Book English, Wicomico County Shed Permits, Two Guns Breakfast Menu, Pokemon Shining Opal Mikachu Evolution, Swing Seat Replacement Fabric, Take A Break Facebook,